Stories from the University of Cambridge
Open Enzyme Collection
-
Jenny Molloy[1], Chiara Gandini[1], Felipe Buson[1], Fernán Federici[2], Tamara Matute[2], Isaac Núñez[2], Anibal Arce[3], Isaac Larkin[4], Scott Pownall[5]
1 Department of Chemical Engineering and Biotechnology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK 2 Molecular Genetics and Microbiology Department, Pontifícia Universidad Católica de Chile, Santiago, Chile 3 Department of Chemical and Biological Engineering, Northwestern University, Evanston, USA 4 Free Genes Project, BioBricks Foundation, San Francisco, USA 5 Open Science Network Society, Vancouver, Canada
-
2019
-
Jenny Molloy:
jmc80@cam.ac.uk -
https://openbioeconomy.org/projects/open-enzyme-collections
-
Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (UK), Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (UK), European and Developing Countries Clinical Trials Partnership (European Union), Global Challenges Research Fund (UK), Isaac Newton Trust (UK), Shuttleworth Foundation (South Africa),Volkswagen Stiftung (Germany)
ABOUT THE OPEN-RESOURCE
Background
Access to reagents and consumables in the biotechnology and synthetic biology fields can be a real challenge for some labs around the world. Enzymes in particular require cold-chain shipping and can take weeks to months to be delivered to parts of Africa, Latin America and Asia. Jenny Molloy, group leader of the Open Bioeconomy Lab in the Department of Chemical Engineering and Biotechnology, realised that this challenge came up repeatedly from colleagues at a number of events she attended on open hardware for science. “It was clear that the equipment was one part of the problem. But if you’ve got the equipment, you still need to keep stocking it with reagents and consumables.” As a result, in 2018 Molloy started her Shuttleworth Foundation Fellowship to create an open source toolkit for reagent production, aiming to make biotechnology research more accessible in low- and middle-income countries.
Function
Open Enzyme Collection consists of DNA coding for essential enzymes commonly used in techniques involving reading and editing DNA constructs. The kit enables researchers who encounter challenges to access resources to have the tools to express their
own enzymes.
Development process
The process started with brainstorming with a number of collaborators, around which enzymes and parts should be included in the collection. The next step was to identify which of those were already off-patent. The Open Enzyme team then made some changes to the digital DNA code to ensure successful expression in the lab workhorse bacteria Escherichia coli, and submitted the sequences to the project Free Genes at Stanford University where they were de novo synthesised. Open Enzyme is an ever-growing collection, Molloy said, “During the pandemic we designed the research in diagnostics collection to help groups developing new COVID tests, added different types of proteins and we’re currently extending it again through an open consultation process.”
Target user
Researchers in the molecular biology field located in low- and middle-income countries. Also, whoever has challenges in accessing enzymes for their molecular biology research, education or innovation activities, for whom it would help to have the protein expression tools to produce their own enzymes.
Comparison to other technologies
The key factor that differentiates Open Enzyme Collection from available alternatives is the open source aspect, and curation of the “most useful” DNA in one single toolkit. Although there is a cost for the maintenance of the plasmids and delivery, recipients then have a lot of freedom. Open Enzyme Collection is distributed under an Open Material Transfer Agreement (OpenMTA, https://openmta.org), which means that the resources can be used commercially and also redistributed to other labs. Typically, when plasmids are purchased from commercial suppliers, most of them have non-commercial and non-redistribution clauses unless high fees are paid. “That’s against what we’re trying to do, which is to make sure that resources are more accessible, reduce transaction costs and shorten supply chains, making the waiting time for the material reduced” says Molloy. Molloy and colleagues also started the Reagent Collaboration Network (Reclone) to connect users of the toolkits. This has a forum and monthly meetings where users can present problems for troubleshooting.
However, as Molloy pointed out, “There’s a difference between people having the DNA and people actually producing enzymes, and we’d be interested to understand more about how to move from access to impact.” Close partnerships show that the resources have been used in South America, including labs in Chile, Peru and Colombia. Thailand, Philippines, Ghana, Cameroon, South Africa, Kenya, and Ethiopia are other locations where labs are actively using some aspects of the collection. It has been distributed to 375 student teams worldwide through the international genetically engineered machines competition (iGEM).
IMPACT
Current use
Open Enzyme has reached more than 500 labs in around 50 countries. However, as Molloy pointed out, “There’s a difference between people having the DNA and people actually producing enzymes, and we’d be interested to understand more about how to move from access to impact.” Close partnerships show that the resources have been used in South America, including labs in Chile, Peru and Colombia. Thailand, Philippines, Ghana, Cameroon, South Africa, Kenya, and Ethiopia are other locations where labs are actively using some aspects of the collection. It has been distributed to 375 student teams worldwide through the international genetically engineered machines competition (iGEM).
Successful stories
With access to the enzymes, a Chilean research group led by Dr Fernan Federici has made a number of innovations for COVID-19 diagnostics, and locally produced potato virus diagnostics. Also, due to the fact that “homebrew” enzymes produced with the Open Enzyme Collection are much cheaper than the commercial alternatives, he was able to use these enzymes for educational purposes, running molecular biology practical courses with university students and even developing “take-home” kits during lockdowns.
In Cameroon, a start-up company using the Open Enzyme Collection developed 6 PCR products, which are now being sold for local researchers. This is important in the Cameroonian context because the students, who are often self-funded, struggle to afford the reagents for their projects. Also, reagents can take several months to be delivered because of supply chain issues, which is avoided when they can be sourced from local markets. From the perspective of the company, they have had a lot of recognition as they are the first company in Cameroon to express recombinant proteins commercially; leading to recognition and partnerships with numerous local research institutions and the Ministry of Science.
Open source choice
“The benefit of having the collection as an open source is that it ideally reduces not only any kind of concern about the intellectual property, but also the transaction costs of negotiating licences,” says Molloy. However, this is just the bureaucratic side of the story. Molloy is concerned with making sure the whole manufacturing pipeline is more accessible. The Open Enzyme Collection team is constantly optimising protocols because they recognise that just because they have shipped someone some DNA that codes for the enzyme, the users still need different pieces of instrumentation and several reagents to manufacture enzymes, so Open Enzyme have to go further. In addition to its technological aspect, Molloy is always thinking about what type of troubleshooting and support the users might need. Having a community that can support each other and also improve the collection is Molloy’s next goal. “We want to advance the researchers from users of the toolkit to contributors of new DNA parts and data, so they really benefit from open collaboration, not just open access.”
GOING FORWARD - WHERE TO IN THE NEXT 3-5 YEARS?
“Enzymes manufactured using the Open Enzyme Collection being used for products with real-world applications beyond research. We are looking for proactive partners who are willing to be regional hubs for distribution of the collection, but also for training and supporting the local research community.”
Harry Akligoh, a member of the Open Bioeconomy Lab Ghana Node since 2018 using some of the tools developed by OpenEnzyme. © 2021, Open Bioeconomy Lab, licensed under CC-BY 4.0.
“We want to advance the researchers from users of the toolkit to contributors of new DNA parts and data, so they really benefit from open collaboration, not just open access.”
Jenny Molloy
Map showing in dark blue the countries where Open Enzyme has been currently used. © 2023, Open Bioeconomy Lab, licensed under CC-BY 4.0.